Research & Publications

Journal Articles

Penny Wise, Dollar Foolish: Buy-Sell Imbalances On and Around Round Numbers

2012, Management Science

Utpal Bhattacharya, Craig W. Holden, Stacey Jacobsen

Abstract

This paper provides evidence that stock traders focus on round numbers as cognitive reference points for value. Using a random sample of more than 100 million stock transactions, we find excess buying (selling) by liquidity demanders at all price points one penny below (above) round numbers. Further, the size of the buy-sell imbalance is monotonic in the roundness of the adjacent round number (i.e., largest adjacent to integers, second-largest adjacent to half-dollars, etc.). Conditioning on the price path, we find much stronger excess buying (selling) by liquidity demanders when the ask falls (bid rises) to reach the integer than when it crosses the integer. We discuss and test three explanations for these results. Finally, 24-hour returns also vary by price point and buy-sell imbalances are a major determinant of that variation across price points. Buying (selling) by liquidity demanders below (above) round numbers yield losses approaching $1 billion per year.

Citation

Bhattacharya, Utpal, Craig W. Holden, and Stacey Jacobsen, 2012, “Penny Wise, Dollar Foolish: Buy-Sell Imbalances On and Around Round Numbers,” Management Science 15, 413-431.

Keywords

Cognitive reference points, round numbers, left-digit effect, nine-ending prices, trading strategies